Where it stands
Verified Oct 19, 2026 · Congress.gov & Senate roll call vote No. 234
The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act (H.R. 3633) was introduced on May 29, 2025 and passed the House 294–134 on July 17, 2025. The Senate Banking Committee reported it with a substitute amendment on June 1, 2026. On September 15, 2026, a Senate cloture vote on the motion to proceed failed 49–50 (60 votes needed). Sen. Tillis entered a motion to reconsider, so the bill could come back. It is not law. The Senate version may differ from the House text summarized below.
The big idea: commodity or security?
Today, it's often unclear whether a token is a security (SEC) or a commodity (CFTC). The bill creates a category called a "digital commodity" and splits oversight:
What it would cover (House-passed text): Exclusive jurisdiction over spot (cash) markets in digital commodities on newly registered digital commodity exchanges, brokers and dealers, plus its existing anti-fraud powers.
What it would cover (House-passed text): Token fundraising (primary sales under investment contracts), new disclosure requirements, and issuer and insider sales before a network is "mature." Anti-fraud authority stays in place.
Under Sec. 201, a token sold as part of an investment contract isn't itself a security just because of that sale. The fundraising deal is regulated, not the token forever.
The SEC's 2026 token taxonomy (in force now)
Separately from the bill, the SEC issued an interpretation in March 2026 (Release 33-11412, with CFTC guidance). It sorts crypto assets into digital commodities, digital collectibles, digital tools, stablecoins and digital securities, and it names 16 examples of digital commodities: APT, AVAX, BTC, BCH, ADA, LINK, DOGE, ETH, HBAR, LTC, DOT, SHIB, SOL, XLM, XTZ and XRP. ClarityCheck's "likely digital commodity" rule is built on this list. Read it in the Federal Register.
- 1Is it a USD payment stablecoin from a centralized issuer whose structure fits the GENIUS Act "payment stablecoin" model?Rule R1 · Confidence capped below High until the GENIUS Act takes effect.YesPayment stablecoinNo
- 2Is the token named as a "digital commodity" in the SEC's March 2026 interpretation?Rule R2 · Confidence then depends on corroborating signals (R3): CFTC filings, CFTC-regulated futures, a US spot ETF.YesLikely digital commodityNo
- 3Has a court or regulator held that the token itself is a security, or do the issuer's own legal documents treat it as a fund share or security?Rule R4 · Used only with a strong official basis.YesLikely security-type riskNo
- None of the aboveRule R5 · includes tokens with only market signals (ETFs, listings) but no official classificationUnclear
"Mature blockchain system" certification
Sec. 205 sets up a process for certifying to the SEC that a blockchain system is mature, broadly meaning no person or group controls it. It sets out statutory conditions, and the SEC can add other sets of conditions. Certification matters because insiders face lockups and sales limits, and issuers face extra disclosures, until the network is mature. Sec. 202 also creates an exemption from traditional securities registration for certain primary sales of digital commodities.
Registered exchanges, brokers & dealers
Platforms would register with the CFTC as digital commodity exchanges, brokers or dealers, with an expedited/provisional registration path (Sec. 106). Exchanges must follow core principles including listing standards, trade surveillance, conflicts-of-interest rules and system safeguards. Customer assets go to qualified digital asset custodians. To list a token, a registered entity certifies it to the CFTC, which has up to 80 days to review (Sec. 403).
DeFi & self-custody
- Self-custody: Sec. 105 affirms the right of US individuals to lawfully hold and transact with their own digital assets.
- DeFi exclusions (Secs. 309 & 409): validating, publishing software, building wallets, providing user interfaces and developing blockchain systems are excluded from SEC/CFTC regulation. Anti-fraud and anti-manipulation authority still applies.
- Developers (Sec. 109): non-controlling developers and blockchain service providers aren't treated as money transmitters just for providing certain infrastructure.
Stablecoins: the GENIUS Act is already law
Payment stablecoins are covered by a separate law, the GENIUS Act (S. 1582), signed July 18, 2025 (Public Law 119-27). Treasury says the expected effective date is January 18, 2027. From then on, issuing a payment stablecoin in the US generally needs a federal or state license. From July 18, 2028, US platforms may only offer payment stablecoins from licensed issuers. Implementing rules from Treasury and the OCC are still proposals.
Anti-CBDC title
The House-passed text includes Title VI, the "Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act." It bars Federal Reserve banks from offering certain products or services directly to individuals and from issuing a central bank digital currency, directly or indirectly. Not verified: whether this title survives in the Senate substitute.
What a "likely security-type risk" token looks like Fictional examples
NewCo Token (fictional example) Security risk
FICTIONAL EXAMPLE: a token sold to fund a startup, with the team controlling the roadmap, would face SEC securities rules under the House-passed bill until the network is certified mature.
YieldX Share (fictional example) Security risk
FICTIONAL EXAMPLE: a token paying holders a share of company profits is a classic investment contract.
FAQ
Is the CLARITY Act law?
No. H.R. 3633 passed the House 294–134 on July 17, 2025. A Senate cloture vote failed 49–50 on September 15, 2026. As of October 19, 2026 it is not law.
Is XRP a security?
The SEC's March 2026 interpretation lists XRP as a digital commodity example. In SEC v. Ripple (2023), the court held that Ripple's institutional XRP sales were investment contracts, but its programmatic exchange sales were not. The final judgment ($125M penalty) stands after the appeals were dismissed in August 2025. ClarityCheck rates XRP a likely digital commodity with medium-high confidence.
Is Bitcoin a commodity?
Yes, very likely. The CFTC has called BTC a commodity in enforcement filings, and the SEC's March 2026 interpretation names it a digital commodity. CFTC-regulated futures and US spot ETFs also exist.
What is a payment stablecoin?
Under the GENIUS Act (law since July 18, 2025), a payment stablecoin is a dollar-pegged token issued by a permitted issuer and redeemable for a fixed amount of money. The Act's expected effective date is January 18, 2027.
What is a 'mature blockchain system'?
Under the House-passed CLARITY Act, it means a blockchain that no person or group controls. Certification would end extra disclosure and insider-sale limits.
Sources
- Congress.gov: H.R. 3633 actions
- Senate roll call vote No. 234 (Sep 15, 2026)
- House Financial Services section-by-section (Jul 2025)
- Bill text (engrossed in House)
- SEC Release 33-11412 (Federal Register, Mar 23, 2026)
- Congress.gov: GENIUS Act, Public Law 119-27
- Treasury: GENIUS Act proposed rulemaking (Aug 17, 2026)
This is an educational summary, not legal advice.